-
Kevin: "Asterisq just released Mentionmap, an exciting web app for exploring your Twitter network. Discover which people interact the most and what they're talking about. It's also a great way to find relevant people to follow." It's a very good tool to see your network, not only in terms of people you're most connected to but also the topics that they are talking about.
-
Kevin: Ian Betteridge summarises a discussion that he had on Twitter with a number of digital journalists including Matthew Ingram and John Robinson. Ian puts forward an interesting argument that people too focused on what readers need and forgetting what people want engage in a "puritan reductionism" and "paternalism".
"But if you treat journalism as some kind of “enabler of effective citizenship” you will never produce stories which are compelling, interesting, provoke real emotion – and yes, which entertain too." -
Kevin: Zoe Kleinman writes: "Children who blog, text or use social networking websites have better writing skills than those who do not, according to the National Literacy Trust." A survey of 3,001 children aged nine to 16. "Of the children who neither blogged nor used social network sites, 47% rated their writing as "good" or "very good", while 61% of the bloggers and 56% of the social networkers said the same."
-
Kevin: Google CEO Eric Schmidt writing in the Wall Street Journal says: "Video didn't kill the radio star, and the Internet won't destroy news organizations. It will foster a new, digital business model." It's especially delicious to see Schmidt use Murdoch's words against him in one of his own publications. "…as Rupert Murdoch has said, it is complacency caused by past monopolies, not technology, that has been the real threat to the news industry."
-
Kevin: A fascinating visualisation looking at the wide variations in income across New York's various neighbourhoods. This is what visualisation is about: Allowing people to easily see patterns in large amounts of information. This shows you the median income of the people living in various neighbourhoods and income distribution of the household in that neighbourhood or borough. Bravo.
-
Kevin: Matt Brittin, Google UK MD, told a Parliamentary committee hearing: "Google delivers 'something like' four billion clicks to news organisations and publishers per month, he said. "Once those clicks go through to sites those are people reading stories and engaging in advertising."
"It's wrong to paint us as stealing content (…) The amount of traffic that comes from us is equivalent to 100,000 clicks a minute to newspaper sites."
Google's 'snippets' of text were in-line with worldwide copyright law, he claimed."
-
Kevin: "The Twitter "back channel" can be a powerful tool to quickly knit a gathering of strangers into an online community, a place where attendees at meetings broadcast bits of sessions, share extra information such as links, and arrange social events. But the same technology can also enable a "virtual lynching.""
Daily Archives: December 4, 2009
Why does a blog look like a blog?
Smashing Magazine has an article titled The Death of the Blog Post, wherein UX designer Paddy Donnelly examines a trend amongst web designers to play with their blog’s design and layout in what he calls a “blogazine” – a blog with a magazine-style layout. Donnelly’s main point seems to be that he, and other designers, find traditional blog designs boring, and feel that that each post deserves to have its own design to service its own needs, rather than have to fit in with a single blog-wide design.
I can understand why this is deeply attractive to designers. The creative freedom to tailor a page’s design perfectly to fit the text must be something designers often crave. And the examples he gives, particularly those from Dustin Curtis, look lovely. But the idea of designing each post afresh is only going to work for a very tiny minority of bloggers with the time and skills. For the vast majority of bloggers, this is just not an option.
But more than that, conflating blog and magazine is a really bad idea.
In unpicking why, we have an opportunity for some important lessons for enterprise. The first is that your blog design really, really matters. There is no excuse for you not to have a beautifully, professionally designed blog that is readable, accessible, and flexible enough to be read on different monitors or devices. If your blog is just slapped onto your corporate website with the same navigation, styling and layout as the rest of the site you should get it redesigned right now. No excuses.
The next lesson is relevant not just to enterprise, but also to web designers shifting from site design to blog design: Blog design patterns matter.
When you look at a well-designed blog you will see a number of features that I call “blog furniture”. There are many pieces of blog furniture to choose from, and not all blogs use all pieces, but most use a combination of:
- Calendar
- Search
- Categories
- Archives
- Recent posts
- Recent comments
- Meta information (e.g. the admin sign-in link, RSS feed link)
- RSS feeds from other sources, e.g. Delicious, Twitter, or news headlines
- Badges from third party sites, e.g. Flickr badges
- About the Author text, photo or link
- Blogroll or list of external links
- Tag lists or tag clouds
These are really important not just because they are useful, but because they provide the visual cues that tell visitors they are somewhere different from the rest of the site, somewhere more personal, more conversational, more informal. Take those cues away, and you risk confusing your readers, even if only momentarily.
If I pitch up on a page that looks just like the rest of the site – or, indeed, nothing like any other page on the site – then it’s going to take me a while to understand what it is and what it’s for. When we arrive on a new site, we give it less than a second to impress us. If the visuals conflict with the content, for example, we are expecting to see a blog but we are presented with something that looks like a magazine, we are less likely to hang around. The fact that it looks pretty isn’t going to make up for that moment of disconnection. (In this precise case, designers may be the exception, but that also means they are profoundly unable to judge whether or not a page causes a conflict of expectations.)
Thirdly, RSS matters. A cornerstone of the blogging world, RSS strips out all design and present, very simply, passages of text interspersed with any graphics. Donnelly’s post looks awful in RSS. Compare and contrast:
From the website
From the RSS feed
A blog post that reads in a disjointed way, with too many graphics, in your RSS reader is going to be a post you don’t bother to finish. Beautiful layouts that rely on the juxtaposition of text and image to make their point are likely to fail horribly in RSS.
I would say that if you’re creating a site with lots of bespoke pages, no blog furniture, which loses its coherence in an RSS reader, you’re not actually writing a blog at all: you’re using blogging software as the backend of a website. Now, there’s nothing wrong with that and I’m glad that such talented designers are flexing their online creative muscles. But let’s not confuse our spades and our shovels.
Over the last ten years blogs have evolved conventions because those conventions are useful. There is no reason why those conventions should hamper design, but you throw them out at your peril.